The movie of Dead Poets Society
talk about a profesor that makes the difference in a institution were control
and order was the only way of teaching. Mr. Keating
was that professor that change the perspective of the students and makes them
to fall in love with poetry. However, he was not a traditional professor and
that was a problem to the school. Mr. Keating was totally different professor from
other classes; he teaches poetry using sports and walking outside the
classroom. His class was relaxed and that was the defense because the students
were exited about it they did not feel obligated. For my experience literature
classes (not this year) was mostly the same, they try to put everything for one
perspective; everything is definitions and a lot of boring books that I read years
ago. Mr. Keating was more that a teacher for those students, he was a role
model. This class makes a partnership “the dead poets society” that makes this
group of friends more close to each other, more than they real parents. This
friendship was powerful and encourages each other to be part of something else.
For example Neil encourages Todd to participate in the Dead Poets Socity.
This new experience makes the boys change in some many ways like Neil
was following his dream and let it go all his fears about not be the perfect
student that dreams to be a doctor; Todd was shy in the beginning of the movie
and then he was the first rebel student that was standing in the table of the
classroom. This kind of changes was very difficult to them because Welton was a
school of boys that represent the best students ever. We can compare Chris’
school that was mix (boys and girls) and Welton: Chis school was normal and
Welton was very strict in every aspect.
Mr. Keating was the captain (Oh Captain, my Captain) of the internal journey
of this students. For example Todd a super shy student and Keating makes him
improve a poem in front of the class, Keating help him to let out his talents
and makes feel Todd like a very special student when he thought that he was
nothing important. In the other hand the captain choose to be silent when Neil
said that his father knows about the play because he is just a guide not his
father. However his mother stay in silent when her son was suffering. When
something like that happens to me in life I prefer to stay in silent sometimes
you don’t understand the full complication of the situation, I can understand
the point of view of Keating. Also I can relate to Keating reaction because he
was his teacher and teachers have this line of personal problems that they
can’t pass. Maybe I’m old fashion but if a professor is to close to you he
can’t teach you that well because he will be supporting you in a lot of stuff,
teacher should be a little strict, it’s the only way the student can respect
the class.
Nail suicide was an exaggeration because there was other options like at
the age of 18 he can do whatever he wants and start his career as an actor. I
try to understand why he did that but I can’t, but if I were in a depression like
he was I probably can’t think that clear as I can think right now. Something
that I did not like was that the school was searching for someone to blame
about this tragedy. The only person that we can blame (apart of Nail, it was a
suicide not a homicide) is Mr. Perry with “You’re going to Harvard, you are
going to be a doctor”. Maybe this could
work on Nail before Mr. Keating class, but it’s was too late, Nail at the end
of the movie was a free thinker. He prefer to suicide than be something that he
is not. Mr. Keating was nothing but a good mentor and he lost his job. After
all the boys sign a document incriminating Mr. Keating. From my point of view I
would not sing the document because they own all the freedom that they had to
Mr. Keating. The professor teaches more than poetry he was teaching about life
and honor. Part of have honor is to be loyal to all those things that they
learned as a student in the class of Mr. Keating. Teach poetry or any kind of
literature needs passion because art needs to be like that, full of freedom. We
can learn to be free, it’s no easy but music, literature and poetry can help us
in the journey.